Area 01
Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law
Initiating enforcement proceedings to collect a receivable, overcoming objections, and carrying out the attachment and sale stages.
Matters handled
- Enforcement proceedings with and without a judgment
- Enforcement based on negotiable instruments
- Objecting to a payment order and actions to set aside the objection
- Precautionary attachment
- Attachment, valuation and sale
- Setting aside a foreclosure sale
- Enforcement through bankruptcy proceedings
How enforcement proceedings begin
The document you hold determines the route to follow. If there is only an invoice or a verbal debt relationship, proceedings without a judgment apply; if there is a cheque, promissory note, or bill of exchange, the procedure specific to negotiable instruments applies; if there is a court judgment or a document having the effect of one, proceedings with a judgment apply.
This distinction is not a matter of preference: the objection period, the grounds for objection, and whether the proceeding will be suspended all depend on the route chosen. Proceedings started on the wrong basis may have to be started over months later.
Before enforcement begins
Clarifying the basis and the amount of the receivable before filing saves time at later stages. The date from which interest is claimed, and at what rate, depends on whether the debtor is in default; for receivables without a fixed due date, a formal notice is usually needed for this.
If there is a risk that the debtor will dispose of assets, a precautionary attachment may be requested before or together with enforcement (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code, Art. 257). As a rule, a precautionary attachment requires a receivable that is due and not secured by a pledge; the court usually requires security from the creditor. Once the order is obtained, the law sets short periods for executing it and then for starting enforcement or bringing an action.
Step by step
- Request for enforcement: The creditor files a request with the competent enforcement office stating the amount of the receivable, its basis, and the interest claimed (Art. 58).
- Payment order: The enforcement office sends the debtor a payment order. Proper service affects the validity of every later stage.
- Objection or finality: If the debtor objects in time, the proceeding is suspended; if not, it becomes final.
- Attachment: Once the proceeding is final, the creditor requests attachment. Immovable property and vehicle records, bank accounts, salary, and receivables held by third parties are searched and attached.
- Valuation and sale: The value of the attached property is determined, and it is put up for public auction on the creditor's timely request.
- Distribution: The sale proceeds are distributed among creditors in the order set by law. If the receivable is not fully covered, the creditor is issued a certificate of insolvency.
If the payment order is objected to
In proceedings without a judgment, if the debtor objects within seven days of service of the payment order, the proceeding is suspended. At that point the creditor has two options: bringing an action to set aside the objection, or, if the available document is sufficient, requesting that the objection be removed.
In an action to set aside the objection, if it is proven that the receivable was unjustly delayed by the objection, compensation for denial of debt may also be claimed. The conditions for this claim are interpreted narrowly and it must be requested in the initial petition.
In proceedings based on negotiable instruments, an objection does not, as a rule, suspend the proceeding. The debtor must raise the objection before the enforcement court and, in most cases, provide security.
Attachment and sale
Once the proceeding becomes final, the debtor's assets can be attached. In practice the most effective steps are attaching immovable property and vehicle registrations, and bank accounts.
The law sets a limit for salary attachment: less than a quarter of the salary may not be attached, but the whole amount may not be attached either. A retirement pension is, as a rule, not subject to attachment; the debtor's consent can change this rule.
A request for the sale of attached property must be made within the periods set out in the law. If a sale is not requested in time, the attachment lapses and the process must be restarted.
When bankruptcy proceedings make sense
If the debtor is a capital company or a merchant, the creditor also has the option of enforcement through bankruptcy proceedings. This route aims at the liquidation of all the debtor's assets and payment to creditors according to the ranking table.
Bankruptcy does not always produce a faster result. If the debtor's assets are limited and there are other creditors ahead of you, the amount collected may fall short of expectations. For this reason, a bankruptcy request calls for a separate assessment.
Documents to prepare
Having the following documents together at the first assessment makes it easier to start enforcement on the right route and for the right amount:
- The basis of the receivable: contract, invoices, delivery notes, order correspondence, current account statement
- The original cheque, promissory note, or bill of exchange, if any; in negotiable-instrument proceedings the original is handed over to the enforcement office
- A certified copy of any court judgment or document having the effect of one
- Any formal notice sent, together with proof of service
- The debtor's identity or tax number and known addresses; for a company, its trade registry details
- A breakdown of any partial payments made
Deadlines
The most common cause of losing a right in this area is a missed deadline:
- Objecting to a payment order: seven days from service (proceedings without a judgment, Art. 62)
- Objecting to the signature and the debt: five days in negotiable-instrument proceedings (Arts. 168, 170)
- Action to set aside an objection: one year from notification of the objection (Art. 67)
- Complaint against an act of the enforcement office: seven days from becoming aware of it (Art. 16)
When you receive a notice, note the date and seek an assessment without delay.
Common mistakes
- Choosing a route that does not fit the document; for example, proceeding by general attachment while holding a negotiable instrument and so forgoing the options it provides
- Stating the interest start date and rate without a basis; excessive interest becomes a ground for objection and prolongs the proceeding
- Starting enforcement without checking the debtor's current address; improper service can undermine later stages
- Failing to claim compensation for denial of debt in the initial petition of an action to set aside an objection
- Not requesting the sale in time after attachment; the attachment lapses
- On the debtor's side, leaving the payment order unanswered: once the seven-day period has passed, the possibility of objecting to the debt is largely closed
How long it takes
The duration depends on the debtor's conduct and the state of their assets. A proceeding that is not objected to becomes final shortly after service of the payment order; the attachment, valuation, and sale stages, however, can take months.
If an action has to be brought following an objection, the duration extends according to the court's workload and the state of the evidence. It is therefore realistic to plan around two scenarios from the outset: one where the debtor does not object, and one where the debtor resists at every stage.
Frequently asked questions
I have received a payment order. How much time do I have?
In enforcement proceedings without a court judgment, you may file an objection with the enforcement office within seven days of service of the payment order. If no objection is filed within this period, the proceedings become final and the attachment stage begins, even if you had valid grounds to dispute the debt.
In proceedings based on negotiable instruments (bills of exchange, promissory notes and cheques), the period is five days and the objection is filed with the enforcement court.
I have objected. What can the creditor do?
Your objection stops the proceedings. If the creditor holds sufficient documentary evidence, they may ask the enforcement court to remove the objection, or they may file an action for annulment of the objection before the general courts.
If your objection turns out to be unjustified, you may be ordered to pay compensation for unjustified denial of the debt.
Can my entire salary be attached?
No. A salary cannot be attached in full, and the attached portion cannot be less than one quarter; as a rule, one quarter of the salary is attached. Maintenance claims are an exception to this limit.
As a rule, a retirement pension cannot be attached; however, the position changes if the debtor has consented to the attachment.
Related guides and articles
Process guide
How enforcement proceedings without a judgment unfold
The route for a creditor with no court judgment: the steps from the request to attachment and sale, the time limits, and the objections that may arise.
Other practice areas
Request an appointment
Share the documents and the stage of your enforcement and bankruptcy law matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.

