Skip to contentMert Sümbül Law Office

Area 08

Defective Consent Actions

The invalidity of contracts and transfers on grounds of mistake, fraud, duress and lack of capacity.

Matters handled

  • Rescission on grounds of mistake
  • Claims of fraud and deception
  • Cases of duress
  • Claims of lack of capacity
  • Unfair advantage (gabin)
  • Abuse of a power of attorney
Request an appointment

Defective consent

A contract may be rescinded if one party's consent was formed under the influence of mistake, fraud, or duress. The contract is not treated as void from the outset; it remains valid until the right of rescission is exercised.

The common difficulty in these actions is proving, with external evidence, a fact that concerns an internal state of mind.

Mistake

Not every mistake is grounds for rescission. The mistake must be fundamental, that is, it must concern a point forming the basis of the contract (Code of Obligations, Arts. 30, 31). A mistake as to the nature or quantity of an immovable property is a typical example.

A mistake as to motive (expectation) alone is not, as a rule, sufficient; it must have been known to the other party and have formed the basis of the contract (Art. 32).

Fraud

In fraud, the other party misleads through intentional conduct (Art. 36). Silence, too, can amount to fraud: concealing a fact that ought to have been disclosed falls within this category.

Concealing the zoning status of an immovable, existing annotations on it, or construction defects, are commonly encountered fraud claims in the sale of real estate. Where the fraud comes from a third party, the other party must have known or ought to have known of it.

Duress

A party who entered into a contract under a threat creating a serious and imminent danger to their own, or their relatives', life, health, assets, or honour is not bound by the contract (Art. 37). It makes no difference whether the threat came from the other party or a third party.

Announcing that a right will be exercised, such as stating that enforcement proceedings will be brought, is not as a rule duress; the position changes if an excessive benefit has been obtained in this way.

Exploitation

Where there is a clear disproportion between the performances, and it arose by exploiting the injured party's distress, inexperience, or lack of judgment, the injured party may declare that they are not bound by the contract, or ask for the contract to be upheld with the disproportion removed (Art. 28).

Lack of capacity

A contract entered into by a person who lacked the capacity to distinguish right from wrong at the time of the transaction is void from the outset (Civil Code, Art. 15). Advanced age, dementia, serious illness, or heavy medication use can form the basis of such a claim.

In these files, medical records, hospital reports, and witness statements are assessed together; the court frequently requests a forensic medical examination.

How rescission is exercised and what follows

The right of rescission is exercised by a declaration addressed to the other party; bringing an action is not always required for this. In practice, however, the declaration is usually made by a written notice, and an action is brought for the return of what was given or for correction of the title deed record.

A rescinded contract is treated as invalid from the outset. The parties reclaim what they gave each other under the rules on unjust enrichment; if immovable property was transferred, a title deed cancellation and registration action follows. In the case of mistake, a party who was at fault in making the mistake may have to compensate the other party's loss (Art. 35).

Step by step

  1. Chronology: The circumstances in which the contract was made, and when the mistake or threat came to light, are set out with dates.
  2. Preserving evidence: Correspondence, messages, advertisement texts, medical records, and witness details are gathered.
  3. Choosing the legal ground: Mistake, fraud, duress, exploitation, or lack of capacity; each has its own time limit and burden of proof.
  4. Declaration of rescission: Written notice is given to the other party within the time limit.
  5. Action and interim measures: If needed, an action for return or for title deed cancellation is brought, and an interim measure is requested to stop the property changing hands.

Documents to prepare

  • Documents of the contract or transfer, title deed records
  • Correspondence before and after the contract, advertisement and promotional texts
  • Bank records showing whether and how much was paid
  • Documents showing the asset's value at the date of the transaction
  • For a lack-of-capacity claim, medical reports, discharge summaries, and medication records
  • Details of people who witnessed the events

Deadline and proof

For mistake, fraud, and duress, the right of rescission must be exercised within one year of becoming aware of the situation, or of the effect of the duress ceasing (Art. 39). Once this period has passed, the contract becomes valid.

For exploitation, the period is one year from becoming aware of the inexperience or lack of judgment, or from the end of the distress, and in any event five years from the conclusion of the contract (Art. 28). There is no such time limit for a claim of lack of capacity. For this reason, which legal ground to rely on must be carefully determined before bringing an action.

Common mistakes

  • Missing the one-year period in the belief that it is exercised only by bringing an action
  • Continuing to perform the contract after learning of the defect; this may be interpreted as a waiver of the right of rescission
  • Requesting medical records late in a lack-of-capacity claim; some records take time to obtain
  • Not requesting an interim measure before the property is transferred to a third party
  • Relying on a single legal ground without raising the others in the alternative

Other practice areas

Title Deed Cancellation and Registration ActionsReal Estate LawActions Arising from Enforcement LawSports LawEnforcement and Bankruptcy LawAll areas

Request an appointment

Share the documents and the stage of your defective consent actions matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.