Skip to contentMert Sümbül Law Office
Article

Delay in a flat-for-land construction contract and the landowner's rights

When delivery is late, the landowner has three routes: specific performance, delay compensation or termination. Which to choose depends on the stage of construction.

Establishing the delay

First, the delivery date in the contract and any additional-time conditions must be identified. Provisions that time may be extended for reasons such as obtaining a permit or a zoning change often appear in the contract.

Showing that the delay is attributable to the contractor is the basis of the later claims.

The landowner's options

When the contractor is in default, the landowner grants an appropriate additional period. If delivery does not take place by the end of that period, the landowner can either demand delivery together with compensation for delay, waive delivery and claim compensation for the loss, or withdraw from the contract.

A choice to waive delivery or to withdraw must be notified to the contractor immediately; the route chosen determines the subject of the later action.

Specific performance and additional time

If construction is at an advanced stage, keeping the contract alive and demanding delivery is often the most realistic route. On this route the contractor is given an appropriate additional period and the process is monitored closely.

Giving the additional time in writing ensures that the procedural requirement is met should termination become necessary later.

Delay compensation

For independent units not delivered, the rental income that could not be earned during the delay may be claimed. The amount is determined through an expert examination on the basis of comparable rents.

If a contractual penalty has been agreed in the contract, whether loss of rent can also be claimed separately depends on the wording of the contract.

Termination

If construction is at a low stage or the contractor has abandoned the work entirely, termination comes into play. After termination, cancellation of the shares already registered in the title deed is requested.

A point to watch in termination is the independent units sold to third parties: the position of good-faith buyers is assessed separately.

Termination with prospective or retroactive effect

If construction has reached a stage close to completion, undoing the contract retroactively can lead to inequitable results. In that case, case law leans towards termination with prospective effect and an assessment in proportion to the work done.

The actual stage of construction is therefore one of the most important facts of the case and is usually determined by expert examination.

Gathering evidence

To establish the delay and the stage reached by construction, evidence can be recorded through the court. Dated photographs, municipal and building inspection records, and correspondence with the contractor support this.

It is important to have evidence recorded before the condition of the building changes, for example before work continues with another contractor.

A common mistake in practice

The most common mistake is giving notice of termination directly, without sending the contractor a formal notice or granting time. In that case the termination may be treated as unjustified and the landowner may face a compensation claim.

Documents to prepare

  • The notarised flat-for-land construction contract and its annexes

  • The title deed record and a list of shares already transferred to the contractor

  • The building permit, project and building inspection reports

  • Formal notices, notices granting additional time and correspondence

  • Information on comparable rents

This article is prepared for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Each dispute must be assessed on its own facts.

Request an appointment

Share the documents and the stage of your real estate law matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.