Skip to contentMert Sümbül Law Office

Area 03

Commercial Litigation

Contractual disputes between companies, commercial receivable actions, and disputes arising from negotiable instruments.

Matters handled

  • Commercial receivable actions
  • Breach of contract and compensation
  • Current account disputes
  • Actions based on cheques and promissory notes
  • Declaratory actions for non-liability and return of payment
  • The commercial mediation process
Request an appointment

What a commercial case is and where it is heard

Disputes relating to the commercial enterprises of both parties, and actions arising from matters regulated in the Turkish Commercial Code, are commercial cases (Turkish Commercial Code, Art. 4). They are heard by the commercial court of first instance; where there is no separate commercial court, the civil court of first instance sits as a commercial court.

Whether a case is commercial determines not only which court hears it, but also the mediation requirement, the type of interest, the rules of evidence, and how certain periods run.

Mediation before litigation

In commercial cases, mediation is a condition of the action for receivable and compensation claims whose subject is the payment of a sum of money (Art. 5/A). An action brought without first going to a mediator is dismissed on procedural grounds.

Mediation is not a formality: if an agreement is reached, the resulting document has the effect of a judgment and can be enforced directly. Being prepared for the session matters as much as the litigation itself.

Step by step

  1. Gathering documents and sending notice: The contract, invoices, and correspondence are brought together; a formal notice is sent to the other side if needed.
  2. Mediation: For monetary and compensation claims, a mediator is approached first. If no agreement is reached, the final report is attached to the statement of claim.
  3. Statement of claim: The claim, its grounds, and the evidence are set out in the petition. Adding evidence later is restricted.
  4. Exchange of pleadings: The defence, reply, and rejoinder define the scope of the claim and the defence.
  5. Preliminary examination: The court checks the procedural conditions and identifies the points in dispute; the parties are encouraged to settle.
  6. Taking of evidence: Commercial books are examined, a court-appointed expert report is obtained, and witnesses are heard.
  7. Judgment and appeal: The judgment may be appealed to the regional court of appeal and, where the conditions are met, to the Court of Cassation.

Organising the evidence

In commercial disputes, the outcome is often determined not by legal argument but by how well the documents are organised. Contracts, order forms, delivery notes, invoices, current account statements, and e-mail correspondence together form a whole picture.

Between merchants, failing to object to an invoice or account statement within the required period can be treated as acceptance of its content (Art. 21). For this reason, objection periods should be tracked from the moment the receivable arises.

Properly kept commercial books can be used as evidence in disputes between merchants. Complete opening and closing certifications of the books matter in this respect (Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 222).

Breach of contract

In supply, dealership, distribution, and service agreements, disputes generally arise on three points: the time of performance, defective goods or services, and whether termination was carried out in accordance with the proper procedure.

Even in termination for just cause, failing to comply with the contract's notice and grace-period requirements weakens a compensation claim. A declaration of termination is a step that is difficult to correct afterwards.

Between merchants, statements such as a notice of default or a notice of termination must be made through a notary, by registered letter with return receipt, by telegram, or by registered electronic mail (Art. 18/3). A penalty clause agreed by a merchant cannot be reduced on the ground that it is excessive (Art. 22); this possibility should be taken into account when the contract is signed.

Jurisdiction and arbitration

A jurisdiction clause in the contract determines in which city the case will be heard; an arbitration clause determines that the dispute will go before an arbitrator instead of a court.

These clauses are often placed at the very end of the contract, where they receive the least attention, yet they are the first thing examined once a dispute arises.

Interest and limitation periods

The type and rate of interest applicable in commercial matters vary according to the nature of the receivable and the contract. The difference between advance interest and statutory interest can reach significant amounts in long-running files.

Limitation periods also differ by type of receivable; even where the general period appears to have expired, an acknowledgment of the debt or a partial payment may have restarted it.

Documents to prepare

  • The contract between the parties, its annexes, and any amendment protocols
  • Order forms, delivery notes, delivery reports, and invoices
  • The current account statement and any reconciliation letters
  • E-mails and other correspondence between the parties
  • Formal notices sent, with proof of service
  • Originals or certified copies of any cheques or promissory notes
  • Commercial book entries and the related accounting records

Deadlines

  • Objecting to an invoice: eight days from receipt of the invoice, between merchants (Art. 21/2)
  • General limitation period: ten years; five years for periodic obligations such as rent and interest (Code of Obligations, Arts. 146, 147)
  • Appeal: two weeks from service of the judgment (regional appeal and cassation, Code of Civil Procedure, Arts. 345, 361)

Common mistakes

  • Treating mediation as a formality and attending unprepared, or starting it with an understated amount
  • Failing to object in writing within eight days to an invoice considered unjustified
  • Giving notices of termination or default by e-mail or telephone; between merchants the statutory form must be observed
  • Leaving the certifications of the commercial books incomplete, which makes it harder to rely on them as evidence
  • Overlooking a jurisdiction or arbitration clause and bringing the action in the wrong forum
  • Claiming a receivable without specifying the type of interest

Frequently asked questions

Can I file a lawsuit directly for a commercial receivable?

For commercial receivables and compensation claims concerning the payment of a sum of money, applying to mediation is a mandatory precondition to filing a lawsuit. A lawsuit filed without first going to a mediator is dismissed on procedural grounds.

If the agreement document is signed jointly by the parties, their lawyers and the mediator, or an enforceability annotation is obtained, it has the force of a court judgment.

What happens if I do not object to an invoice?

Between merchants, failing to object to an invoice or account statement within the period set by law may result in its content being deemed accepted.

For this reason, an invoice should be checked as soon as it is received, before the objection period runs out.

Am I bound by the jurisdiction clause in the contract?

A jurisdiction clause validly agreed between merchants determines which court will hear the dispute. If there is an arbitration clause, the dispute is resolved by arbitrators instead of a court.

Although these clauses often appear at the end of a contract, they are among the first provisions examined when a dispute arises.

Related guides and articles

Other practice areas

Banking and Finance LawSuretyship and SecurityContract and Obligations LawCollusion and Avoidance ActionsDefective Consent ActionsAll areas

Request an appointment

Share the documents and the stage of your commercial litigation matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.