Skip to contentMert Sümbül Law Office

Area 04

Banking and Finance Law

Disputes arising from loan agreements, realising security, and objecting to banking transactions.

Matters handled

  • Collecting loan receivables
  • Objecting to an account-closing notice
  • Enforcement through the realisation of a mortgage
  • Suretyship disputes
  • Declaratory actions for non-liability and return of payment
  • Objections to interest and expenses
Request an appointment

Commercial loan or consumer loan

The first question in a credit dispute is the purpose for which the loan was used. A loan given to a company, or to an individual for their business activity, is a commercial loan; the dispute is heard by the commercial court of first instance, and mediation is mandatory before litigation for monetary claims (Turkish Commercial Code, Art. 5/A).

Housing, vehicle, and personal loans used for private needs are consumer loans.

The documents of a credit relationship

In credit disputes, the backbone of the file is three documents: the loan agreement, the account statement, and the account-closing notice. A defect or procedural error in these documents affects the entire proceeding.

If the account-closing notice was not properly served, this can support the argument that default never occurred and that the proceeding was therefore initiated prematurely.

Step by step

  1. Closing the account: When payments fall into arrears, the bank closes the credit account and makes the entire debt due.
  2. Notice: The account-closing notice is served on the debtor and the guarantors; default arises at the end of the period given in the notice.
  3. Enforcement: Depending on the type of security, proceedings without a judgment, enforcement through realisation of the mortgage, or proceedings based on a negotiable instrument are started.
  4. Objection: The debtor and guarantors object to the debt, the interest, and the procedure, within periods that vary by type of proceeding.
  5. Action or sale: An action is brought following the objection, or, once the proceeding is final, the security is put up for sale.

Realising security

For a mortgage-secured receivable, the route to follow is enforcement through the realisation of the mortgage. This is subject to a different procedure from proceedings without a judgment, and the available grounds for objection are limited.

Whether the mortgage is a maximum-amount mortgage or a principal-amount mortgage determines which receivables fall within its scope (Civil Code, Art. 851). This distinction directly affects the amount that can be claimed.

The guarantor's position

Suretyship is a commonly used form of security in credit relationships, but its validity is subject to strict formal requirements. The guarantor must write the maximum liability amount and the date in their own handwriting, and for married guarantors the spouse's written consent is required (Code of Obligations, Arts. 583, 584).

A defect in these requirements can render the suretyship invalid. The duration and scope of the guarantor's liability are also assessed separately.

Actions brought by the debtor

A credit debtor may bring a declaratory action for non-liability, arguing that no debt exists or that the calculated amount is excessive. If payment has already been made, an action for the return of payment may be brought instead.

Interest being applied contrary to the contract, and unfounded expense and commission items, are common subjects of such actions.

Restructuring negotiations

Restructuring can be negotiated with the bank before or after enforcement begins. When signing a restructuring protocol, the following matter as much as the new maturities: whether accrued interest is added to the principal, whether existing security and suretyships remain in place, whether new security is required, and what happens if payments fall into arrears.

A protocol may amount to an acknowledgment of the debt. If the debt or the amount is to be disputed, this should therefore be assessed before the protocol is signed.

Setting aside a foreclosure sale

At the stage where the security is sold, a claim that the sale was conducted improperly is raised through a request to set aside the sale. The period is very short, and a low sale price alone is not sufficient grounds for setting it aside; a procedural error or an element of loss must be shown.

Documents to prepare

  • The general loan agreement, its annexes, and the repayment schedule
  • Disbursement and payment receipts, account statements
  • The account-closing notice and its date of service
  • The mortgage deed, pledge agreement, or suretyship agreement
  • Correspondence with the bank and any restructuring protocols
  • If enforcement has started, the payment order and the enforcement file details

Deadlines

  • Action for return of payment: one year from payment (Art. 72)

Common mistakes

  • Disregarding the account-closing notice and failing to object to the account statement in time
  • Applying without first establishing whether the loan is commercial or a consumer loan; the wrong forum costs time
  • Signing a restructuring protocol without seeing a breakdown of the debt and the interest
  • Accepting a guarantor's liability without examining the formal requirements of the suretyship agreement
  • Missing the deadline at the sale stage and being unable to raise the irregularity

Other practice areas

Suretyship and SecurityContract and Obligations LawCollusion and Avoidance ActionsDefective Consent ActionsTitle Deed Cancellation and Registration ActionsAll areas

Request an appointment

Share the documents and the stage of your banking and finance law matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.