Conditions for compensation for denial of debt in an action to set aside the objection
Compensation for denial of debt, the sanction for an unjustified objection, cannot be claimed in every file. The liquid receivable requirement and the timing of the claim are decisive.
Purpose of the compensation
Compensation for denial of debt is intended to deter a debtor from delaying the proceedings through an unjustified objection. It partly compensates the creditor for the delay suffered.
Time limit for bringing the action
An action to set aside the objection is brought within one year of the objection being served on the creditor. For commercial money claims, applying to a mediator before filing the lawsuit is mandatory; this period does not run while mediation is ongoing.
After the period has passed, the receivable can still be sued for under the general rules, but the existing enforcement proceedings can no longer be relied on.
The liquid receivable requirement
For the compensation to be awarded, the receivable must be liquid, that is, of a kind the debtor could determine by a simple calculation.
In files where the amount is determined through an expert examination or a contested assessment, liquidity is generally not accepted. By contrast, receivables whose amount can be understood directly from the contract or the invoice are regarded as liquid.
It must be requested
The compensation is not awarded automatically; it must be expressly requested in the statement of claim. A request raised later generally has no effect.
The rate
The law sets the lower limit of the compensation to be awarded as a certain percentage of the receivable. The court may increase this rate according to the particulars of the file.
This lower limit is twenty per cent of the receivable. The compensation is calculated on the amount for which the objection is set aside; if the objection is set aside only in part, compensation is awarded only for that part.
Removal of the objection
If the receivable is based on a document of the kind listed in the law (such as an acknowledgement of debt whose signature is admitted or notarised, or an official document), removal of the objection can be requested from the enforcement court instead of bringing an action. This request is made within six months of service of the objection.
This route is faster, but the review is limited to the document; the debtor's defences on the merits may be heard in a separate action.
On the debtor's side
If it turns out that the objection was not unjustified but the proceedings were, bad-faith compensation in favour of the debtor comes into play. Both compensations are two faces of the same logic.
For this reason, when deciding whether to object, it should be assessed whether the objection genuinely has a legal basis.
Documents to prepare
The enforcement request, payment order and objection
A document showing the date the objection was served
The contract, invoices, delivery notes and current account statement
Formal notices and correspondence with the debtor
For commercial receivables, the final mediation report
This article is prepared for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Each dispute must be assessed on its own facts.
Request an appointment
Share the documents and the stage of your actions arising from enforcement law matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.

